Very few Australian frameworks name a penetration test outright. SMB1001 does at its top tier, Diamond, which calls for annual penetration and social engineering testing. APRA's CPS 234 requires a systematic testing program for regulated financial entities, without fixing a test type or a date. PCI DSS includes penetration testing for businesses that handle card data. The Essential Eight does not require one at all. Most of the time, the "you need a pen test" request comes from a contract, a tender or an insurer, so the document you should read first is the one in front of you, not a framework.
That matters because the source of the request decides the scope, the frequency and who is allowed to do the work. Below is what each framework says about penetration testing compliance requirements in Australia, quoted where we could confirm the wording, and where we see businesses over-buy or under-buy. If you already know you need a test, our penetration testing team scopes it against the framework or contract that asked for it.
Who is asking you for a pen test, and why it matters
The requests we see from clients usually arrive in one of four ways: a renewal question from a cyber insurer, a security questionnaire from a larger customer, a tender clause, or a framework audit. Each has a different meaning.
- A framework requirement has defined wording, and an auditor will check your evidence against it.
- A contract or tender clause is binding, but its scope is whatever the clause says, which is often vague.
- An insurer question usually asks whether you have tested, not how. Answer it truthfully and keep the report.
- A customer questionnaire is often a box someone copied from another questionnaire. Ask what they actually need to see.
Before you book anything, find the exact sentence that asks for the test. It tells you what has to be in scope and how often.
Which frameworks require a penetration test: the short comparison
| Framework | Who it applies to | Does it name a pen test? | How often |
|---|---|---|---|
| SMB1001 | Businesses that choose to certify | Yes, at Diamond | Annually |
| APRA CPS 234 | APRA-regulated entities | No. It requires systematic testing of control effectiveness | Commensurate with risk; program reviewed at least annually |
| ISM | Government systems and organisations that adopt it | Includes security testing controls | Check the current ISM controls for your system |
| Essential Eight | Anyone who adopts it; government entities | No | Not applicable |
| PCI DSS | Businesses that store, process or transmit card data | Yes | At least annually and after significant change |
SMB1001: annual testing at Diamond only
SMB1001, published by Dynamic Standards International, is a certification standard for small and medium businesses with five tiers, each adding controls to the one before. Bronze, Silver and Gold are self-attested by a director. Platinum and Diamond are externally audited.
Penetration testing appears at Diamond, alongside social engineering testing, and the requirement is annual. Platinum stops at vulnerability scanning of internet-facing systems. So if a customer asks for SMB1001 Gold, they are not asking for a pen test, and if they ask for Diamond, a single test is not enough: you need one every year, and the findings fixed. We cover the tiers in more detail on our SMB1001 certification page.
APRA CPS 234: systematic testing, not a fixed annual test
CPS 234 applies to APRA-regulated entities: banks and other authorised deposit-taking institutions, general, life and private health insurers, and superannuation RSE licensees. It says an entity "must test the effectiveness of its information security controls through a systematic testing program". The nature and frequency of that testing must match the rate at which threats change, how critical and sensitive the information is, the consequences of an incident, exposure to untrusted environments, and how often the systems change.
There is no line that says "one penetration test a year". In practice a pen test is one of the methods an entity uses inside that program. Three other requirements matter to anyone selling testing into the sector:
- Testing must be done by "appropriately skilled and functionally independent specialists".
- Deficiencies that cannot be fixed in a timely manner must be escalated to the Board or senior management.
- The entity must review whether its testing program is sufficient at least annually, or after a material change.
CPS 234 also reaches suppliers. Where a third party manages a regulated entity's information assets and the entity relies on that party's testing, the entity must assess whether that testing is adequate. If you are an SMB supplying a bank, insurer or super fund, that is usually why their questionnaire asks about your testing.
The ISM: read the current controls for your system
The Information Security Manual from the Australian Signals Directorate is written for government systems, and some private organisations adopt it or have it written into government contracts. It includes security assessment and testing controls. The ISM is updated regularly, and which controls apply depends on the system and its classification, so we do not paraphrase a frequency here.
If a government contract names the ISM, ask the contracting agency which controls are in scope for your system and what testing evidence they expect. Then scope the test to that answer, not to the whole manual.
Essential Eight: no test required, but testing proves the controls
The Essential Eight is eight mitigation strategies: application control, patching applications, Microsoft Office macro settings, user application hardening, restricting administrative privileges, patching operating systems, multi-factor authentication and regular backups. Penetration testing is not one of them, and reaching a maturity level does not depend on having one.
Where a test helps is evidence. An Essential Eight assessment asks whether a control works, not only whether it is switched on. A tester who tries to run unapproved code, escalate privileges or get past MFA shows you whether application control, admin restrictions and MFA hold up in your environment. A pen test supports an Essential Eight assessment but does not replace one, because ASD's assessment process guide sets out how an assessor tests each control against the maturity model. For SMB clients we tie annual testing to both Essential Eight and SMB1001 evidence, so one test serves both. See our Essential Eight page for how assessments work, and Essential Eight vs SMB1001 if you are choosing between them.
ASD announced in June 2026 that it will retire the Essential Eight, and it published its replacement, ASD Essentials, on 15 October 2026. Both stay on cyber.gov.au during a transition, and no mandatory changeover date has been set. Our Essential Eight to ASD Essentials transition tracker follows the changes.
PCI DSS, contracts and insurers: where most requirements really come from
PCI DSS applies to entities that store, process or transmit cardholder data, or that could affect the security of the cardholder data environment. Version 4 includes internal and external penetration testing at least once every 12 months and after significant changes. Whether you must validate compliance, and how, is set by your acquirer or the card brands, not by the PCI Security Standards Council. Many small merchants reduce their scope by using a hosted payment page, so check with your payment provider before you pay for a test of a system that never sees a card number.
Contracts and insurers are the most common source of all. A clause that says "annual independent penetration test" is a requirement once you sign it, and it usually says nothing about scope. Agree the scope in writing with the customer before the test, or you may test the wrong thing and still fail the next questionnaire.
Does it have to be certified?
Usually the framework does not say. CPS 234 asks for skilled and functionally independent specialists. A contract may ask for a CREST-accredited provider, and here the detail matters. CREST International states that its formal relationship with CREST ANZ ended at the end of April 2019, and that CREST ANZ membership alone is not recognised by CREST International as equivalent to its accreditation. If a contract names CREST, ask which one. Our guide to the best penetration testing companies in Australia covers how to compare providers.
What you should do now
Find the sentence that asks for the test. Pull the contract clause, tender requirement, insurer question or framework control. Note what it says about scope, frequency and who may test.
Match the scope to that sentence. An SMB1001 Diamond audit, a bank's supplier questionnaire and a PCI DSS assessment need different scopes. One test can often cover two of them if it is planned that way from the start.
Plan to fix and retest. A report full of open findings is weak evidence. Our engagements end when findings are remediated and retested. Talk to our penetration testing team on 1300 EPIC IT and we will scope the test against the requirement you actually have.
Frequently asked questions
Is penetration testing a legal requirement in Australia?
For most private businesses, no general law requires a penetration test. Penetration testing compliance requirements in Australia come from specific frameworks such as SMB1001 Diamond and PCI DSS, from APRA's CPS 234 testing program for regulated financial entities, and most often from contracts, tenders and insurers.
Does the Essential Eight require a penetration test?
No. Penetration testing is not one of the eight mitigation strategies, and a maturity level does not depend on one. A test is still useful evidence that controls such as application control, admin restrictions and MFA work in practice.
How often does CPS 234 require penetration testing?
CPS 234 does not set a fixed frequency for penetration tests. It requires a systematic testing program whose nature and frequency match the threats, the criticality and sensitivity of the information, and the rate of change, and the program must be reviewed at least annually.
Which SMB1001 tier requires a penetration test?
Diamond, the highest tier, includes annual penetration testing and social engineering testing. Platinum includes vulnerability scanning of internet-facing systems but not a penetration test, and Bronze to Gold do not require either.
Does a compliance pen test have to be done by a CREST-certified company?
Only if the framework, contract or customer says so. Many penetration testing compliance requirements in Australia ask for skilled, independent testers rather than a named certification. If CREST is named, confirm whether CREST International accreditation is meant, as CREST ANZ membership alone is not recognised as equivalent.


